Insurance agent or double agent?

A few of our property owning clients seemed confused when I advised them that we handle all their claims personally. Their previous suppliers had been settling claims on behalf of the insurance company. This article highlights how not all insurance suppliers are the same, how to check and what to do if you’re shocked to find your supplier is not on your side.

Welcome back, or if you’re new here sign up to our RSS feed to receive insurance tips, new posts, plus details of events and promotions that could help you or your network reduce the risks facing their organisation.

Who pays the claims?

The insurance company will, ultimately, yet sometimes they will have authorised an agent to manage claims and write cheques on their behalf. This is supposed to speed up the process yet there’s a hidden downside. Agents that pay out less in claims get a bonus from the insurance company. This bonus can amount to hundreds of thousands of pounds. Faced with arranging payment of a few thousand and losing thousands in return is just too tempting for some people. Morals and money are not good friends.

How can you tell it’s possible?

The FSA thinks these practices are OK. They insist providers make it clear in their documents. Look out for small print stating “we act on behalf of the insurer when settling claims”. It may not be clear but it must be on there somewhere. Most people are surprised when the service they expected doesn’t materialise. Yet the clues are always in the T&Cs.

What if your expectation isn’t met?

Policies can be cancelled if they are not a “minimum and deposit” wording. As long as a claim has not occurred, refunds can be obtained. If they refuse to refund their fees in a huff it’s not good news. I’ve heard of some suppliers hiding the fact they collect 48% of the annual investment. It’s never too late to check small print (unless the paperwork gets damaged before you get around to it). The law of the sod is the number one law of insurance.

Wrap up: Not all agents are independent. It’s not always easy to tell at first glance. Look again.

Top tip

A quick flick through the documents that detail your cover will determine exactly whose side an agent is on.

Who to share this with: Property Owners, Facilities Managers, Business owners that rely on their premises to stay in business.

Free insurance healthcheck

Connect with us

Latest posts

Worried about subsidence? Why your Insurance Broker matters

We were contacted by one of our property-owning clients who was dealing with water leaks in the underfloor heating pipes in one of his tenanted flats. His tenant had moved out because of all the disruption. And our client was obliged to give a substantial £500 rent...

Why do you need an insurance broker?

As a business owner, you already have enough on your plate. Between managing staff, serving customers, and planning for growth, insurance can often feel like just another task on an ever-growing to-do list. Many businesses buy insurance simply because they know they...

How We Streamlined a Water Damage Insurance Claim

Water damage in rented properties can quickly become stressful for landlords, especially when multiple parties, timelines, and repair works need to be coordinated. In this case, our Claims Manager, Lisa, supported a landlord through a water damage escape incident...

Blown Away: A Real Example of Why Insurance Matters

Imagine investing in a stunning, high-end outdoor kitchen—only to have it destroyed overnight by a storm. Not through any fault of your own, but because a neighbour’s tree came crashing down on it. This was exactly the situation one of our clients faced. And it’s a...

When A Work Phone Gets Stolen

When a Stolen Phone Doesn’t Mean Interruption to your Business Losing a work phone can feel like a small disaster—especially when it contains important contacts, emails, and access to business systems. For one of our clients, this became a reality when an employee’s...