Solicitors frustrated by broker tactics

Now silly season is upon us, I thought I would update you on what is actually happening in the solicitor’s indemnity market. I know quite a few solicitors and I understand their frustrations. Rather than wax lyrical, I’m going to stick to the good, the bad and the ugly in the current market.

Welcome back or if you’re new here and find it useful, get the latest posts by signing up to RSS feed or send an email titled Free Info.

The good

There are a lot of hard working brokers out there who are satisfied that they have strong enough relationships with their clients and are not using “hard ball” tactics to scare their clients into renewal. You probably have one of those on your side and your terms and conditions will be reasonable.

Ensure you provide full and detailed information when requesting your renewal terms.

The bad

There are two realities to explain. A solicitor received his form, returned it and was given terms within 48 hours. He was also given 7 days (make that 5) to make his mind up. That’s not even legal.

Another practice (with the same supplier) has incorrect “claims” on the practice’s record and the supplier is refusing to correct them. Naturally, they are worried that the terms will be provided late and prove onerous.

The ugly

Some practices (mainly SP’s) have been refused terms by their current insurer already and are filling out forms (more in desperation than hope) whilst considering their future if they cannot find cover. Their supplier should have helped them with the complicated forms.

The reason for declinature is not being made clear or doesn’t add up. One broker refused to tell their client which insurance companies they had approached. That is not service as it leaves the policyholder with no real options.

Wrap up: Some suppliers are great at maintaining relationships and have secured excellent terms. Others are playing hard ball when they do provide terms, taking advantage of the fact that the competition need time to offer an alternative. Some are being obstructive or abandoning clients they cannot easily help.

Top Tip

If an application is declined request a detailed reason before applying elsewhere.

Free insurance healthcheck

Connect with us

Latest posts

Worried about subsidence? Why your Insurance Broker matters

We were contacted by one of our property-owning clients who was dealing with water leaks in the underfloor heating pipes in one of his tenanted flats. His tenant had moved out because of all the disruption. And our client was obliged to give a substantial £500 rent...

Why do you need an insurance broker?

As a business owner, you already have enough on your plate. Between managing staff, serving customers, and planning for growth, insurance can often feel like just another task on an ever-growing to-do list. Many businesses buy insurance simply because they know they...

How We Streamlined a Water Damage Insurance Claim

Water damage in rented properties can quickly become stressful for landlords, especially when multiple parties, timelines, and repair works need to be coordinated. In this case, our Claims Manager, Lisa, supported a landlord through a water damage escape incident...

Blown Away: A Real Example of Why Insurance Matters

Imagine investing in a stunning, high-end outdoor kitchen—only to have it destroyed overnight by a storm. Not through any fault of your own, but because a neighbour’s tree came crashing down on it. This was exactly the situation one of our clients faced. And it’s a...

When A Work Phone Gets Stolen

When a Stolen Phone Doesn’t Mean Interruption to your Business Losing a work phone can feel like a small disaster—especially when it contains important contacts, emails, and access to business systems. For one of our clients, this became a reality when an employee’s...